From Whisper to a Scream
- Jessica Mance
- Jun 19
- 6 min read
I never wanted to tell this story. Not to friends, to strangers, not online, and definitely not publicly. And if I’m being honest, I spent years trying to make sure I never had to.
People see the ending and can assume that’s where the story began. They hear about the divorce. Maybe there are mentions of police reports. They hear about court orders.
They see me speaking openly about domestic violence and assume I wanted to expose what happened. Sorry, but the truth is much MUCH more complex than that.
I truly never wanted any of it.
I wanted my marriage and to grow old with that person. I wanted my family to stay intact, and make good memories together.
I wanted my children to grow up with two healthy parents under one roof. I wanted the life we promised each other. I wanted healing and peace.
So when things began to break down, I did what many people do. I looked at myself first. Maybe it was me.
Maybe I wasn’t patient enough, understanding enough, too emotional, or I expected too much. Maybe if I worked harder, loved better, communicated differently, prayed more, forgave faster, everything would finally change.
So I got to work. I changed. And changed. And changed again. I read books. I sought counseling. I prayed. I reflected. I learned healthier ways to communicate.
I examined my own behavior relentlessly. I took responsibility for every piece that belonged to me.
And if I’m honest, I took responsibility for pieces that never belonged to me at all. Because I desperately wanted to save my family. And to be honest, I was terrified with what life would look like as a single Mom. I knew I would have to face an incredible amount of discomfort, and family court would be hell.
I knew because I watched it happen with my own parents.
There is another truth I have learned to hold alongside all the others.
I was not perfect, and I had my part in it too.
When my marriage began to unravel, I was carrying wounds I didn’t fully understand. I was carrying trauma, fear, abandonment, and pain that accumulated over a lifetime. And yes, there were times I bled on the people closest to me.
Including him. Not because I wanted to hurt him, and not because I was malicious.
Wounded people often react from wounds they haven’t yet learned how to heal. And for a very long time, I carried shame about that.
Today, I carry responsibility instead. And there is absolutely a difference.
The wounds themselves were not my fault, and the childhood I survived was not my fault. The losses I carried were not my fault. But healing became my responsibility.
And eventually, I accepted that responsibility. I went to meetings, I sought help. I took a difficult inventory of myself with someone I trusted who had the experience of doing the work herself.
I sought to learn healthier ways to communicate. I learned how to sit with uncomfortable emotions instead of handing them to someone else. And I learned how to stop expecting other people to heal wounds that only I could address.
That work changed my life. And not because it saved my marriage. It didn’t.
Not because it erased the past. It couldn’t.
But because it allowed me to look honestly at my own reflection and say: I was hurting, I made mistakes, and I caused pain. And I was willing to do something about it.
I truly believed that if I healed myself, everything else would heal too. But there was always the cycle. No matter how much progress I made, no matter how much hope I carried, and no matter how many promises I believed.
The cycle remained. It was the same confusion, same pain, and the same feeling of never being heard. The same feeling that no matter how carefully I chose my words, they would never truly land. I realized I was merely negotiating with a deeply destructive problem, and it really would never go away. And it would just end up eating me alive.
For years, I whispered. I whispered through tears. I whispered through prayers. I whispered through conversations held behind closed doors. I whispered because I believed problems should be solved privately. I whispered because I loved my family with all of my heart. And I whispered because I was trying to save it.
People think the scream comes first. It doesn’t. The scream comes after years of whispers. After years of hoping. After years of believing that if you could just find the right words, the right timing, the right version of yourself…everything would finally be okay.
The scream is what happens when every whisper falls on deaf ears. And the hardest realization of all was understanding that accountability only works when everyone involved is willing to practice it. I eventually became willing to own my side of the street.
What absolutely broke my heart was realizing that owning my side could never repair a relationship by itself.
I never wanted to call the police. I never wanted to become so desperate that I believed I needed outside help just to leave safely. I never wanted my life to reach that point.
And oh my God…I never wanted my children to experience the loss that followed.
I never wanted a reality where they would grow up without their father present in their lives anymore. That was like a knife that went in and got twisted. Watching that grief was horrifying.
That grief still exists. It always will. But I guess then…that was the point of the exercise. Like a permanent limb removal that didn’t seem necessary, and would have to adapt to.
Losing those things carries its own heartbreak. The dreams that died. Even when leaving is necessary, and even when leaving is right.
And I hold the pieces of it everyday. I wake up and go to sleep making sure the kids are going to be OK.
Just me.
People often imagine healing as choosing a side. It’s love or truth. Compassion or accountability. Forgiveness or honesty.
Experience has taught me that sometimes we must hold all of them at once.
WHAT THEY BUILT AFTER
Today, I tell the truth about what happened. And yes, I practice forgiveness. Every single day.
I forgive myself for the years I spent believing everything was my fault. I forgive myself for staying longer than I should have. And I forgive myself for not knowing then what I know now.
And I really pray for the father of my children. Not out of obligation, denial, but out of hope. The kind of hope that recovery taught me. And the kind that carried me through my own darkest moments.
I pray that one day he finds healing. I pray that one day he finds peace. And I pray that one day grace finds him the same way grace found me. Because I know what it feels like to be broken. I know what it feels like to carry pain you don’t know how to put down.
And despite everything that happened, I still believe it is possible.
The truth is, I never wanted a scream. I begged for a conversation. I pleaded for understanding. I wanted my family, and I wanted to be heard.
The scream only arrived after years of discovering that the whispers had fallen on deaf ears.
Now is the radical acceptance that helped me move forward with my life with as much dignity as possible.
Writing about this years later does not mean I am still trying to change the outcome.
And it does not mean I am stuck in the past. I walked away. I ultimately made that choice.
Time keeps moving forward whether we are ready or not. I don’t spend my days wishing for a different history.
I no longer ask myself what would have happened if I had said the right thing, done the right thing, become the right version of myself.
The truth is that I don’t write about these things because I can’t let go.
I write about them because I finally have, to keep creating the beauty from the ashes, and allow myself to receive what’s next.
With a voice that remains steady and strong in all ways…..
Comments